We find ourselves in a world in which technology is advancing at a supersonic pace. Advancements are being made so quickly that we are sometimes unable to take the time we need to adapt to the constant change around us. In our modern era, we find ourselves beginning to question, “Is this technology actually helping us? Or is it actively harming?”
The ability for two people to communicate verbally over great distances has existed for less than 200 years. It’s a technological advancement that, throughout most of human history, would have sounded inscrutable. Our phones are as much a part of our daily routine as a pair of shoes.
Today, many parents face a decision: Should they give their child a phone?
A cell phone provides peace of mind and a level of security for both the child and parent. The child knows that if they need to get in contact with their parent, all they have to do is call or text, and the parent has the peace of mind of having a direct line of communication with their child.
In addition, parents are faced with the dilemma, “How early is too early to get my child a phone?” A phone provides a comforting tether from parent to child. But nowadays smartphones are more like miniature computers or tablets rather than devices used for making calls. This is where issues arise.
Screen time itself has become a growing concern for many families. Beyond smartphones, children today are spending increasing amounts of time on tablets, computers, televisions, and gaming devices. While technology can provide educational opportunities and entertainment, excessive screen time may interfere with sleep, physical activity, social interaction, attention span, and emotional well-being. Finding a healthy balance between technology use and offline activities is becoming more important than ever during childhood development.
Phone addiction is not necessarily the problem, as few children (or adults) find themselves unable to stop making phone calls. Rather, it is everything else the cellular devices offer that causes so many individuals to be stuck in the dopaminergic loop of being unable to put their phone down. The real issue is smartphone addiction. Whether it be games, YouTube, or social media, devices nowadays operate as an unlimited source of boredom relief.
One of the biggest challenges with screen time is that it often replaces activities that are critical for healthy development, such as outdoor play, face-to-face interaction, reading, hobbies, and uninterrupted sleep. Younger children, in particular, benefit from opportunities to explore, create, and engage with the world around them without constant digital stimulation.
Giving your child one of these devices, even while monitoring their use, results in neural pathways being formed to crave easy stimulation. For example, problematic TikTok use has been an issue since the platform itself was created. Its algorithm is designed to hook each user by curating a personalized feed of content the individual is most likely to enjoy. This results in users finding themselves spending far more time on the app than anticipated or intended, and for some, finding it a massive challenge to close or stop opening the app.
These repetitive patterns can encourage compulsive behaviors and make it difficult for children and teens to disengage from their devices. YouTube Shorts are a variation of the same theme. Targeted content for users of all ages makes even toddlers relentlessly scroll through YouTube. And try taking a cell phone away from a toddler or young child! The resulting tantrum may rival that of a teenager whose phone has been locked by a parent!
When it comes to the issue of deciding when to get your child a phone, there really is no one-size-fits-all approach, as long as you are not getting your child a smartphone during their early development. Under a very limited set of circumstances, it may be justifiable to get your elementary-aged child a flip phone or another type of dumbed-down cell phone.
For many young children, limiting access to smartphones and social media platforms may help support healthier emotional and behavioral development. In fact, the argument, backed by emerging data on mental health decline and social media use, can be made to keep smartphones out of the hands of teenagers as well. In fact, some countries have now limited social media use for children under the age of 16 years.
By extension, the argument of limiting social media use and content scrolling, in essence, the usual bulk of screen time, can also be applied to tablets with internet access and computers.
For some families, simpler phones with limited features may offer a healthier balance, providing communication and safety without constant access to social media and endless content scrolling.
Find a TopLine MD Alliance Network provider today
The TopLine MD Alliance was created by physicians who came together to make healthcare experiences better for patients and simplify the complex healthcare system. We help patients navigate this system every day, connecting them with top-of-the-line healthcare providers, practices, diagnostic centers, and imaging centers we trust.
The TopLine MD Alliance brings together high-quality care and exceptional service while ensuring that you are always satisfied with your choice of medical providers. In addition to dermatology and primary care, our specialties include family medicine, internal medicine, pediatrics, women’s health, and many more.
To get started, find a provider near you today.
The TopLine MD Alliance is an association of independent physicians and medical practice groups who are committed to providing a higher standard of healthcare services. The members of the TopLine MD Alliance have no legal or financial relationship with one another. The TopLine MD Alliance brand has no formal corporate, financial or legal ties to any of the physicians or practice groups in the network.
